How to quote?
Differential Diagnosis: Sprained vs. Broken Wrist
Hello Guest
  
  • Login
• Register…
• Start blog
  • Who, Where, When
• What is interesting here?
• Duels
  • Polls
• Avatars
• Interests
  • Cities and Countries
• Random blog
• Users search
  • Search
• Games
• Tests
• GYXU
  • Ñîîáùåñòâà
• Talxy Chat
• Horoscope
• Online
 
Register!

GYXU > Skating > Differential Diagnosis: Sprained vs. Broken Wrist 27 May 2005 02:57:11

  Recent blog posts: 
  Forums:   
  Discuss: 
  Recent forum topics: 
  Recent forum comments:
  Ìîäåðàòîð:

Differential Diagnosis: Sprained vs. Broken Wrist

Ellen Arnold 25 May 2005 05:49:37
 OK, all you folks out there who "aren't a doctor but play one on rssir."

This afternoon I fell while doing CW back crossovers. I still don't know
exactly how; it wasn't the dreaded "click of death" but all of a sudden I
was off my edge and on my butt. Well, actually, I would probably have been
better off had I been on my butt ;-)­ but instead I landed on my hip, left
arm outstretched and hitting the ice wrist first.

I skated another 20 minutes or so while the pain got progressively worse,
then finally got off and started icing it. I stopped on the way home to buy
an Ace bandage and have since alternated between the two while keeping my
forearm elevated as much as possible.

I am in rather excruciating pain (just took two naproxen so hopefully that
will help SOON) and my left arm is essentially useless. Although nothing is
obviously deformed, I do have some swelling.

I am assuming that what I have is "just" a terrifically bad sprain, but I am
wondering: how would I know if it was a broken bone, short of having an
x-ray which i will probably do tomorrow if it's not any better?

When I called my coach to inform her that I might miss my lesson tomorrw,
she said "you know, you can still skate with a broken wrist." Well, probably
so, but at this point I can't imagine pulling on my tights, lacing up my
skates or even, for that matter, fastening my bra ;-)­.

Thanks for any info,
Ellen (not bad for one-handed typing, eh?)

Add comment
Lyle Walsh 25 May 2005 07:04:14 permanent link ]
 
I do more than just play a doctor ;) There is no way to tell other than an
x-ray and it may not even show up for a month! Get an x-ray tomorrow,
repeat it or get a bone scan if the first is negative but you aren't better
in a month. Broken wrists are very common in skating. The danger is a rare
fracture that cuts off the blood to the wrist bone above it, Then if the
bone dies, it'll hurt for the rest of your life, no treatment works. Bummer
to say the least. Get the x-ray, get the x-ray.
Lyle


Add comment
Steve 25 May 2005 13:21:03 permanent link ]
 Hmm, not a doctor but a vet. If you were a dog I'd want an x-ray...

Steve


On Tue, 24 May 2005 19:49:37 -0600, Ellen Arnold
<ellenarnold@sugarl­oaf.net> wrote:
OK, all you folks out there who "aren't a doctor but play one on rssir.">
This afternoon I fell while doing CW back crossovers. I still don't know>exactly how; it wasn't the dreaded "click of death" but all of a sudden I>was off my edge and on my butt. Well, actually, I would probably have been>better off had I been on my butt ;-)­ but instead I landed on my hip, left>arm outstretched and hitting the ice wrist first.>
I skated another 20 minutes or so while the pain got progressively worse,>then finally got off and started icing it. I stopped on the way home to buy>an Ace bandage and have since alternated between the two while keeping my>forearm elevated as much as possible.>
I am in rather excruciating pain (just took two naproxen so hopefully that>will help SOON) and my left arm is essentially useless. Although nothing is>obviously deformed, I do have some swelling.>
I am assuming that what I have is "just" a terrifically bad sprain, but I am>wondering: how would I know if it was a broken bone, short of having an>x-ray which i will probably do tomorrow if it's not any better?>
When I called my coach to inform her that I might miss my lesson tomorrw,>she said "you know, you can still skate with a broken wrist." Well, probably>so, but at this point I can't imagine pulling on my tights, lacing up my>skates or even, for that matter, fastening my bra ;-)­.>
Thanks for any info,>Ellen (not bad for one-handed typing, eh?)

Add comment
Mrs Redboots 25 May 2005 14:18:17 permanent link ]
 Ellen Arnold wrote to rec.sport.skating.i­ce.recreational on Tue, 24 May
2005:
OK, all you folks out there who "aren't a doctor but play one on rssir.">
This afternoon I fell while doing CW back crossovers. I still don't know>exactly how; it wasn't the dreaded "click of death" but all of a sudden I>was off my edge and on my butt. Well, actually, I would probably have been>better off had I been on my butt ;-)­ but instead I landed on my hip, left>arm outstretched and hitting the ice wrist first.>
Owwww! Poor you, what a nasty thing to happen.
I skated another 20 minutes or so while the pain got progressively worse,>then finally got off and started icing it. I stopped on the way home to buy>an Ace bandage and have since alternated between the two while keeping my>forearm elevated as much as possible.>
I am in rather excruciating pain (just took two naproxen so hopefully that>will help SOON) and my left arm is essentially useless. Although nothing is>obviously deformed, I do have some swelling.>
The worst fall I ever had was just before I started lessons, and landed
totally on my left arm - pretended nothing was wrong, but it was several
days before I could wash my face with both hands, or brush my hair.....
I don't think I *did* do any real damage - except to my nerve, which is
why, ten years later, I still can't do a 3-turn solo with any speed!
I am assuming that what I have is "just" a terrifically bad sprain, but I am>wondering: how would I know if it was a broken bone, short of having an>x-ray which i will probably do tomorrow if it's not any better?

I don't think there is any reliable way. In fact, if you've broken a
bone, you may well be better off (unless you've broken it in a very
awkward place) than if you have torn a tendon - you will heal more
quickly. Do take it to the doctor, though - quite apart from anything
else, they will be able to give you better support for it than you can
buy over-the-counter. I'm sure you could have a removable splint if you
wished, rather than a plaster cast (if one is needed) - and they can
give you stronger painkillers, too!
When I called my coach to inform her that I might miss my lesson tomorrw,>she said "you know, you can still skate with a broken wrist." Well, probably>so, but at this point I can't imagine pulling on my tights, lacing up my>skates or even, for that matter, fastening my bra ;-)­.>
Some folks do skate with a broken wrist - I've known several - and
others don't. Again, I've known several. If you do, you do need help
with getting your skates on!

I do wish you better!
--
"Mrs Redboots" mailto:annabel@amsm­yth.demon.co.uk
http://www.amsmyth.­demon.co.uk/
Website updated 23 May 2005


Add comment
Lyle Walsh 27 May 2005 02:57:11 permanent link ]
 that's exactly right, never guess, find out for sure.


"SlingSkate" <isiafs5@aol.com> wrote in message
news:1117105972.000­873.324920@g44g2000c­wa.googlegroups.com.­..> "how would I know if it was a broken bone?"-Ellen>
My experience with doctors is that they always ask what hurts. Then> they ask if it was trauma. IF I say yes. They x-ray me immediately.> I do not recall a doctor ever guessing about a break.>


Add comment
 

Add new comment

As:
Login:  Password:  
 
 
  
 
respect your talk pals, avoid using obscene language, typing entire messages in CAPS, posting buy/sell ads or violating netiquette or the RF Criminal Code..


GYXU > Skating > Differential Diagnosis: Sprained vs. Broken Wrist 27 May 2005 02:57:11

see also:
IRL: Watkins Glen: Vision Racing Friday…
MOTOGP: Italian GP: Saturday practice…
NASCAR-CUP: Dover: Jeff Gordon…
pass tests:
see also:
http://demish.gyxu.com/i/temp/2/128...
...
...

  Copyright © 2001—2009 GYXU
Idea: Miñhael Monashev
See Help and FAQ in the community support.gyxu.com.
Write in the community about the bugs you have noticedbugs.gyxu.com.
Write your offers and comments in the communities suggest.gyxu.com.
Information for parents.
Write us at:
If you would like to report an abuse of our service, such as a spam message, please .