How to take part in discussions on other sites? (e.g. the LiveJournal)
How much is the track to blame...
Hello Guest
  
  • Login
• Register…
• Start blog
  • Who, Where, When
• What is interesting here?
• Duels
  • Polls
• Avatars
• Interests
  • Cities and Countries
• Random blog
• Users search
  • Search
• Games
• Tests
• GYXU
  • Ñîîáùåñòâà
• Talxy Chat
• Horoscope
• Online
 
Register!

GYXU > F1, Indy, Nascar, Rally > How much is the track to blame... 2 June 2005 04:07:20

  Recent blog posts: 
  Forums:   
  Discuss: 
  Recent forum topics: 
  Recent forum comments:
  Ìîäåðàòîð:

How much is the track to blame...

R E D N A L O 30 May 2005 19:51:10
 ..for the way the Coca-Cola 600 played out?

Looks to me like Humpy Wheeler has created a monster. There
were a number of comments by announcers about how much
the characteristics of the track had been changed by Wheeler.
For the good? I don't think so - it was just too dang fast, and
unpredictable (twitchy?); and the track coming apart in a key
area didn't help much either during the race. One of the
announcers made the comment that, "Humpy has created
a big Bristol" (don't know if that is the -exact- quote, but that
was the jest of it).

DR
---
Go 24-48
-------------------­--------
Proud Father of a US Marine
--Semper Fi--

Add comment
Michael McGaha 31 May 2005 00:30:17 permanent link ]
 
<r_e_d_n_a_l_o@mchs­i.com> wrote in message
news:ee9m911c1ve1gk­8r7pad5d18rakfd468mf­@4ax.com...> ..for the way the Coca-Cola 600 played out?>
Looks to me like Humpy Wheeler has created a monster. There> were a number of comments by announcers about how much> the characteristics of the track had been changed by Wheeler.> For the good? I don't think so - it was just too dang fast, and> unpredictable (twitchy?); and the track coming apart in a key> area didn't help much either during the race. One of the> announcers made the comment that, "Humpy has created> a big Bristol" (don't know if that is the -exact- quote, but that> was the jest of it).>

Yeah I heard that too... you know SOMETHING has to be wrong when you set a
new all-time record for caution flags.

Michael

Add comment
John McCoy 31 May 2005 07:45:05 permanent link ]
 r_e_d_n_a_l_o@mchsi.­com wrote in
news:ee9m911c1ve1gk­8r7pad5d18rakfd468mf­@4ax.com:
Looks to me like Humpy Wheeler has created a monster.

I agree with you. I think there's several problems now:

1) the track was lumpy, and the grinding was intended to level the
high spots. The result is that there's places (the low spots) which
the grinder barely touched, and those spots have much less traction
that the ground areas (hence, spin city).

2) the grinding exposed the seams and other weak spots in the
pavement. Thus a lot of patchwork is needed (plus the asphalt is
obviously too thin to support more grinding, so point #1 can't
be corrected).

3) if you're on the optimum line the track is much faster...thus
if you're trying to pass and therefor on the non-optimum line, it's
become very hard to pass. This usually happens when a track gets
faster, it effectively becomes "narrower" and more single-groove.

Problem is, I don't see how you can fix it now, other than to
repave it. And that will mean 4 or 5 seasons of single groove
follow-the-leader racing, until the asphalt wears in.

Incidently, a number of drivers have been quoted in various news
items on the track...I don't beleive I've seen single positive
comment from any driver.

John

Add comment
Chuck Steak 31 May 2005 17:21:56 permanent link ]
 In article <Xns9666E663E2930po­gosupernews@216.168.­3.30>,
John McCoy <igopogo@ix.netcom.­com> wrote:
Problem is, I don't see how you can fix it now, other than to>repave it. >John>

Or maybe 'scuff' the whole surface...
So it is consistent.



Dan
-------------------­--------------------­-------
The biggest difference between marriage and a car battery,
is that the battery has a positive side....



Add comment
Guest 31 May 2005 23:09:37 permanent link ]
 

Chuck Steak wrote:> In article <Xns9666E663E2930po­gosupernews@216.168.­3.30>,> John McCoy <igopogo@ix.netcom.­com> wrote:>
Problem is, I don't see how you can fix it now, other than to> >repave it.> >John> >
Or maybe 'scuff' the whole surface...> So it is consistent.

As stated in another group, I think, like Mikey, that the track is
entirely to blame - because not only did it change, it changed how the
drivers raced, knowing they couldn't pass and there wouldn't be good
side-by-side racing. Schrader, answering, "If you could change one
thing, ...." said he'd change the sanctioning system that NASCAR uses
for the tracks, so if the teams show up to race on a changed track
(like Lowes this year) and the track isn't "good," they can just haul
out of there. Of course, if NASCAR could say yea or nay on a track
change, it would happen before race weekend.

N.

Add comment
Crusader 1 June 2005 01:55:12 permanent link ]
 <ndooley@blue.weeg.u­iowa.edu> wrote in message
news:1117562949.789­917.275710@f14g2000c­wb.googlegroups.com.­..> Chuck Steak wrote:> > In article <Xns9666E663E2930po­gosupernews@216.168.­3.30>,> > John McCoy <igopogo@ix.netcom.­com> wrote:> >
Problem is, I don't see how you can fix it now, other than to> > >repave it.> > >John> > >
Or maybe 'scuff' the whole surface...> > So it is consistent.>
As stated in another group, I think, like Mikey, that the track is> entirely to blame - because not only did it change, it changed how the> drivers raced, knowing they couldn't pass and there wouldn't be good> side-by-side racing. Schrader, answering, "If you could change one> thing, ...." said he'd change the sanctioning system that NASCAR uses> for the tracks, so if the teams show up to race on a changed track> (like Lowes this year) and the track isn't "good," they can just haul> out of there. Of course, if NASCAR could say yea or nay on a track> change, it would happen before race weekend.>
N.>
Seems to me NA$CAR does have control over most of the trax thru ISC.
They have 12 of the 22 trax, 21 of 39 Events, & 19 of 36 Pts races.
CRU


Add comment
John McCoy 1 June 2005 07:03:40 permanent link ]
 Chuck_Steak@nospam.c­om (Chuck Steak) wrote in news:iu-dnXte9-9cyw­HfRVn-
hQ@rcn.net:
In article <Xns9666E663E2930po­gosupernews@216.168.­3.30>,> John McCoy <igopogo@ix.netcom.­com> wrote:>
Problem is, I don't see how you can fix it now, other than to>>repave it. >>John>>
Or maybe 'scuff' the whole surface...> So it is consistent.

I'm not sure you could do that, tho. I get the impression that
the grinding has opened up the seams and other thin spots, hence
all the crack filler and epoxy patches. I'm not sure there's
enough asphalt thickness left to let them do any more work on it.

John

Add comment
Chuck Steak 1 June 2005 18:56:48 permanent link ]
 In article <Xns9667DF654621Dpo­gosupernews@216.168.­3.30>,
John McCoy <igopogo@ix.netcom.­com> wrote:>Chuck_Steak@­nospam.com (Chuck Steak) wrote in news:iu-dnXte9-9cyw­HfRVn->hQ@rcn.net:>
In article <Xns9666E663E2930po­gosupernews@216.168.­3.30>,>> John McCoy <igopogo@ix.netcom.­com> wrote:>>
Problem is, I don't see how you can fix it now, other than to>>>repave it. >>>John>>>
Or maybe 'scuff' the whole surface...>> So it is consistent.>
I'm not sure you could do that, tho. I get the impression that>the grinding has opened up the seams and other thin spots, hence>all the crack filler and epoxy patches. I'm not sure there's>enough asphalt thickness left to let them do any more work on it.>
John

good point...

my gut feeling is, if it needs paving,
it will get paved.
They aren't ones to flinch too badly at that sort of
thing.



Dan
-------------------­--------------------­-------
The biggest difference between marriage and a car battery,
is that the battery has a positive side....



Add comment
Tom Duwe 1 June 2005 19:09:43 permanent link ]
 
"Chuck Steak" <Chuck_Steak@nospam­.com> wrote in message
news:<Gdednahgg-wVI­wDfRVn-gA@rcn.net>..­.

<snip>
good point...>
my gut feeling is, if it needs paving,> it will get paved.> They aren't ones to flinch too badly at that sort of> thing.>
Dan

"They" in this case being Humpy and Bruton, I agree...I think Bruton was
disappointed that his progressive banking didn't work on the initial design at
TMS...so he re-worked it...and re-worked it...and re-worked it (along with
plugging the seepage issues). Now TMS is hyped as (one of the) fastest tracks on
the schedule and offers some of the best racing.

Tom in Bristol...hoping he bites the bullet in Concord, too.

Add comment
Martin X. Moleski 1 June 2005 20:03:18 permanent link ]
 On Wed, 1 Jun 2005 09:09:43 CST, "Tom Duwe" <tomd88@bvunet.net>­ wrote:
"Chuck Steak" <Chuck_Steak@nospam­.com> wrote in message>news:<Gdedn­ahgg-wVIwDfRVn-gA@rc­n.net>...
... my gut feeling is, if it needs paving,>> it will get paved.>> They aren't ones to flinch too badly at that sort of>> thing.
"They" in this case being Humpy and Bruton, I agree...I think Bruton was>disappointed that his progressive banking didn't work on the initial design at>TMS...so he re-worked it...and re-worked it...and re-worked it (along with>plugging the seepage issues). Now TMS is hyped as (one of the) fastest tracks on>the schedule and offers some of the best racing.
Tom in Bristol...hoping he bites the bullet in Concord, too.

There's obviously a black art (pun intended; you may laugh now) in
paving race tracks.

I have a Canadian cousing who did her engineering degree in
asphalt technology.

I don't think anyone knows what effect changes will have until
there is a full race run on a new surface. There are always
unintended consequences that don't show up in testing.

Or another way to put it is that no tests simulate the full
stresses of race day.

There was a very, very funny segment on Inside NC this
week where they showed some poor track worker struggling
to decide what to do with some patches that came loose
on the track. The poor man! Do you pull the loose stuff
out and leave a hole in the track? Do you cut it off?
What will work? Should you stop the race for an hour
to do some epoxy repairs?

In the event, the worker just tucked everything
back as best he could and kicked it a few times. Dunno
how well those spots stood up during the rest of the race.

Marty

Add comment
Martin X. Moleski 1 June 2005 22:19:01 permanent link ]
 On 1 Jun 2005 16:40:09 GMT, ndooley@blue.weeg.u­iowa.edu wrote:
... It wasn't drama so much as crashing - like a supersized Bristol. The>point is, Humpy thought he would get great racing, and he didn't. I>watch to watch racing, passing, racing, not crash, caution, crash,>caution, crash caution.

It does get old--even at Bristol's night race. The first few crashes
are pretty exciting. After the 13th or 14th, it's old hat. :o)

22 cautions x 5 laps each (estimated) = 110 laps under caution
out of 400.
... I think Indy is boring as all get out, and so>was the 600.

I used to watch Indy when I was younger--I especially enjoyed
the bump days. It was the premier racing show on TV
back then. I don't remember any other live racing. I once
watched the ABC crew vamp for more than two hours
while hoping that the rain would go away and let the
track dry. They finally decided to pack it in and run the
race the next day.

Jim McKay always sounded a little short of breath, no matter
what sport he was covering. On the rain-delay day, he was
like a drowning man. I couldn't tear myself away from it.
"Oh, the humanity!"

The CART/IRL split ruined Indy for me. They haven't
won me back yet, but I'm looking at it every year for
different reasons (Robby Gordon, Tony Stewart,
Danica Patrick; time of day--pre-Charlotte hour).

My heart is with CART, but the IRL has the 500 and the
"Indy" trademark. I don't think I've watched any CART
races at all since US 500 in 1996. That's also the first
year that I was involved in rasn, which helped me to pay
more attention to NASCAR than I had been.
Humpy has promised to do something to the track (grind>the so-far unground lines) which will probably make it worse the next>time Cup is there.

I don't think we'll know what will work until we see it working.

Marty

Add comment
Arclight 2 June 2005 04:07:20 permanent link ]
 With what Wheeler charges us for tickets--he could pave the track in gold.


<r_e_d_n_a_l_o@mchs­i.com> wrote in message
news:ee9m911c1ve1gk­8r7pad5d18rakfd468mf­@4ax.com...> ..for the way the Coca-Cola 600 played out?>
Looks to me like Humpy Wheeler has created a monster. There> were a number of comments by announcers about how much> the characteristics of the track had been changed by Wheeler.> For the good? I don't think so - it was just too dang fast, and> unpredictable (twitchy?); and the track coming apart in a key> area didn't help much either during the race. One of the> announcers made the comment that, "Humpy has created> a big Bristol" (don't know if that is the -exact- quote, but that> was the jest of it).>
---> Go 24-48> -------------------­--------> Proud Father of a US Marine> --Semper Fi-- >


Add comment
 

Add new comment

As:
Login:  Password:  
 
 
  
 
respect your talk pals, avoid using obscene language, typing entire messages in CAPS, posting buy/sell ads or violating netiquette or the RF Criminal Code..


GYXU > F1, Indy, Nascar, Rally > How much is the track to blame... 2 June 2005 04:07:20

see also:
NUMP Preseason poll
Re: Trip report from Houghton
pass tests:
see also:
4to za xerj ?
pipiska!!!upja4ka!!!pshli nax!!!
...

  Copyright © 2001—2009 GYXU
Idea: Miñhael Monashev
See Help and FAQ in the community support.gyxu.com.
Write in the community about the bugs you have noticedbugs.gyxu.com.
Write your offers and comments in the communities suggest.gyxu.com.
Information for parents.
Write us at:
If you would like to report an abuse of our service, such as a spam message, please .