What is Atom?
Another question - Blade Angle
Hello Guest
  
  • Login
• Register…
• Start blog
  • Who, Where, When
• What is interesting here?
• Duels
  • Polls
• Avatars
• Interests
  • Cities and Countries
• Random blog
• Users search
  • Search
• Games
• Tests
• GYXU
  • Ñîîáùåñòâà
• Talxy Chat
• Horoscope
• Online
 
Register!

GYXU > General > Another question - Blade Angle 9 March 2005 20:54:41

  Recent blog posts: 
  Forums:   
  Discuss: 
  Recent forum topics: 
  Recent forum comments:
  Ìîäåðàòîð:

Another question - Blade Angle

Andy Nield 9 March 2005 19:21:07
 When you set the stern pitch, does the blade stay at that angle through
the stroke, or does it find it's own angle?

I was on a IA course, and the instructor said it goes in over square
(i.e. the stern pitch angle), and then squares itself in the water
during the drive...

ok, well now I am slightly confused...

I'd previously assumed that the back of the blade collar locked onto
the swivel face and kept the blade at the same pitch through the drive
(ignoring the effects of lateral pitch).

The instructor was sure that stern pitch was just the catch angle, and
the blade then found it's own angle and squared up regardless of the
swivel pitch... Is this correct?

Add comment
Phil 9 March 2005 20:07:31 permanent link ]
 If you ignore torsion in the blade shaft/head, and the effects of
lateral pitch (not negligible unless zero!) - then the pitch of the
face of the blade must be the stern pitch with a blade that has zero
pitch inbuilt.

Add comment
Neil Wallace 9 March 2005 20:26:57 permanent link ]
 Phil wrote:> If you ignore torsion in the blade shaft/head, and the effects of> lateral pitch (not negligible unless zero!) - then the pitch of the> face of the blade must be the stern pitch with a blade that has zero> pitch inbuilt.

Minor correction.
Stern pitch + whatever is built into the gate.

But interesting that you mention torsion in the shaft.

I would wager that the angular deflection along the long axis of the oar
shaft (rotation, if you like) is far from negligable... espescially with the
non-symetrical (i.e.non-macon) blades we use.

I've often wondered whether measurement of this torsion in a crew boat could
indicate who is pulling hardest.

I've also often wondered what sort of tolerance the different manufacturers
accept for the modulus of their shafts.


Add comment
Jon Anderson 9 March 2005 20:34:37 permanent link ]
 Neil Wallace wrote:> I've often wondered whether measurement of this torsion in a crew> boat could indicate who is pulling hardest.

There must be a few strain gauge systems out there to measure how
much your oar bends (as opposed to twists). Some bloke at our club made
one about 12 years ago from a material that changed resistivity when
stretched. He recorded the data on a BBC Micro of all things...

I'm not entirely sure that the blade will "square" itself regardless of
stern pitch though.
If it did, why do we worry about negative lateral pitch decreasing the
stern pitch at the finish of our stroke?

Jon
--
Durge: jon@durge.org http://users.durge.­org/~jon/
OnStream: accounts@rowing.org­.uk http://www.rowing.o­rg.uk/

[ All views expressed are personal unless otherwise stated ]
Add comment
Neil Wallace 9 March 2005 20:54:28 permanent link ]
 Jon Anderson wrote:> Neil Wallace wrote:>> I've often wondered whether measurement of this torsion in a crew>> boat could indicate who is pulling hardest.>
There must be a few strain gauge systems out there to measure how> much your oar bends (as opposed to twists).

yes, I know they are commonplace.
just wondered whether twisting has been done.
I reckon the data would be very interesing for a variety of reasons.
Some bloke at our club> made one about 12 years ago from a material that changed resistivity> when stretched. He recorded the data on a BBC Micro of all things...

oh happy days!

10 mode 7
20 end


Add comment
Walter Martindale 9 March 2005 20:54:41 permanent link ]
 

andy.nield@ps.ge.co­m wrote:> When you set the stern pitch, does the blade stay at that angle through> the stroke, or does it find it's own angle?>
I was on a IA course, and the instructor said it goes in over square> (i.e. the stern pitch angle), and then squares itself in the water> during the drive...>
ok, well now I am slightly confused...>
I'd previously assumed that the back of the blade collar locked onto> the swivel face and kept the blade at the same pitch through the drive> (ignoring the effects of lateral pitch).>
The instructor was sure that stern pitch was just the catch angle, and> the blade then found it's own angle and squared up regardless of the> swivel pitch... Is this correct?>
IA?
Oh well.
If you have confirmed that your blades are zero pitch (acc. to the
manufacturer's specs), and if you have your pin vertical, the pitch
will/should stay the same through the stroke, and that should/will be
the pitch to which your oarlock is set (using the eccentric pitch plugs
in C2, for example). If your pins are pitched outwards (i.e.,
laterally) 1 or more degrees, but vertical relative to fore-aft, the
pitch on the blade will change during the stroke; greater pitch at the
catch, less pitch at the release. The theoretical aim of this lateral
pitch business is to increase the pitch at the start of the drive,
reducing the depth to which you enter, and to decrease the pitch at the
end of the drive, tending to keep the blades buried in the water a
little longer.
The practice I've seen in NZ, Ireland and home here in Canuck land over
the past decade has been to set the pin to vertical, set the gate to 3
or 4 degrees, use (and confirm) zero pitch blades so that the blade has
a chance to stay the same pitch through the stroke.
Walter

Add comment
Douglas MacFarlane 9 March 2005 21:03:12 permanent link ]
 In article <398mdhF5vg52tU1@in­dividual.net>, rowing.golfer*NOSPA­M*@virgin.net
says...>
Phil wrote:>> If you ignore torsion in the blade shaft/head, and the effects of>> lateral pitch (not negligible unless zero!) - then the pitch of the>> face of the blade must be the stern pitch with a blade that has zero>> pitch inbuilt.>
Minor correction.>Stern pitch + whatever is built into the gate.>
But interesting that you mention torsion in the shaft.>
I would wager that the angular deflection along the long axis of the oar >shaft (rotation, if you like) is far from negligable... espescially with the >non-symetrical (i.e.non-macon) blades we use.>
I've often wondered whether measurement of this torsion in a crew boat could >indicate who is pulling hardest.>
I've also often wondered what sort of tolerance the different manufacturers >accept for the modulus of their shafts.>

It will be "Stern pitch + whatever is built into the gate" when the oar is at
right angles to the boat. If the pin is not verticlal then the patch may change
through the stroke, even with zero degrees of lateral pitch.

The pitch is the sum of the pin angle plus the gate pitch plus the oar pitch.
You hope that the gate pitch and the oar pitch don't vary through the stroke.

The angle of the pin, which may be adjustable, sets the axis around which the
gate rotates.

Douglas

Add comment
Carl Douglas 9 March 2005 23:56:41 permanent link ]
 andy.nield@ps.ge.com­ writes>When you set the stern pitch, does the blade stay at that angle through>the stroke, or does it find it's own angle?>
I was on a IA course, and the instructor said it goes in over square>(i.e. the stern pitch angle), and then squares itself in the water>during the drive...>
ok, well now I am slightly confused...>
I'd previously assumed that the back of the blade collar locked onto>the swivel face and kept the blade at the same pitch through the drive>(ignoring the effects of lateral pitch).>
The instructor was sure that stern pitch was just the catch angle, and>the blade then found it's own angle and squared up regardless of the>swivel pitch... Is this correct?>

Doesn't say very much for the quality of the instruction given, Andy!
I sense someone was wandering slightly out of their depth, which really
isn't excusable.

This is a dead simple matter, ably explained already by Douglas &
Walter. I would only add:
1. The more you bend the blade, the less affected you should be by
pitching errors because the blade trails further behind the line from
hand through gate and is thus less twitchy (imagine if the shaft had a
reversed bend!)
2. Pin pitch really does matter, because you can't correct for errors in
pin pitch by altering the inserts in the gate
3. Trying to get your pin vertical if it is not pitch-adjustable is a
damaging & crazy exercise, only achievable on soft riggers

The proper solution is a simple & rigid rigger, combined with a
pitch-adjustable pin. For answers, see below ;^)

Cheers -
Carl
--
Carl Douglas Racing Shells -
Fine Small-Boats/AeRoWin­g low-drag Riggers/Advanced Accessories
Write: The Boathouse, Timsway, Chertsey Lane, Staines TW18 3JY, UK
Email: carl@carldouglas.co­.uk Tel: +44(0)1784-456344 Fax: -466550
URLs: www.carldouglas.co.­uk (boats) & www.aerowing.co.uk (riggers)

Add comment
Stan 10 March 2005 00:39:56 permanent link ]
 andy.nield@ps.ge.com­ wrote in message news:<1110381667.17­4625.112160@l41g2000­cwc.googlegroups.com­>...> When you set the stern pitch, does the blade stay at that angle through> the stroke, or does it find it's own angle?>
I was on a IA course, and the instructor said it goes in over square> (i.e. the stern pitch angle), and then squares itself in the water> during the drive...>
ok, well now I am slightly confused...>
I'd previously assumed that the back of the blade collar locked onto> the swivel face and kept the blade at the same pitch through the drive> (ignoring the effects of lateral pitch).>
The instructor was sure that stern pitch was just the catch angle, and> the blade then found it's own angle and squared up regardless of the> swivel pitch... Is this correct?

While there is possibly some wobble in the gate at the catch. I would
cite the infamous demon of lateral pitch as the usual reason for pitch
variation through the stroke. The effect of 1 degree +ve lateral pitch
would definately produce the effects mentioned at your IA's course.
Add comment
Guest 10 March 2005 02:03:32 permanent link ]
 Vertical pins.....Get ur spirit level out and spend an age getting it
right if necessary, but get it right!

Forget the 1/2 or 1 degree lateral that people will say stops going
deep at the catch, If you need that with a big blade your catch is
wrong.

Add comment
Phil 10 March 2005 12:47:42 permanent link ]
 Minor correction - Stern Pitch being the angle that the back face of
the gate (or swivel in ARA - speak) makes with the vertical ... this
naturally includes what is built into the gate - I did not say "the
angle indicated on the little blue inserts".

Add comment
Phil 10 March 2005 12:52:26 permanent link ]
 Minor correction - Stern Pitch being the angle that the back face of
the gate (or swivel in ARA - speak) makes with the vertical ... this
naturally includes what is built into the gate - I did not say "the
angle indicated on the little blue inserts".

Add comment
Andy Nield 10 March 2005 13:50:11 permanent link ]
 Thanks for the replies.

I'd loosely used the term 'stern pitch' to include total pin/gate/blade
pitch and assumed a vertical pin (probably should have been more
explicit). But even so plenty of helpful replies.

It's just a shame those yellow and blue plastic bits don't come in a
choice of colours so you can match the boat/blade colours... Hey Carl,
how about some colour options...? :)­

Add comment
 

Add new comment

As:
Login:  Password:  
 
 
  
 
respect your talk pals, avoid using obscene language, typing entire messages in CAPS, posting buy/sell ads or violating netiquette or the RF Criminal Code..


GYXU > General > Another question - Blade Angle 9 March 2005 20:54:41

see also:
Re: My new uni game
Singapore Triathlon
pass tests:
see also:

  Copyright © 2001—2009 GYXU
Idea: Miñhael Monashev
See Help and FAQ in the community support.gyxu.com.
Write in the community about the bugs you have noticedbugs.gyxu.com.
Write your offers and comments in the communities suggest.gyxu.com.
Information for parents.
Write us at:
If you would like to report an abuse of our service, such as a spam message, please .