1891 14.1 Kid Nichols 13.9 Jack Stivetts 13.2 Sadie McMahon 11.9 Amos Rusie 11.7 John Clarkson 11.6 Bill Hutchison 11.1 George Haddock 10.6 threshold
1892 17.9 Cy Young 12.9 Bill Hutchison 11.2 John Clarkson 10.4 Kid Nichols 10.3 Gus Weyhing 10.3 Nig Cuppy 9.2 Amos Rusie 8.9 Tim Keefe 8.8 threshold (With only one league, the threshold comes back down some.)
1893 14.7 Amos Rusie 13.0 Cy Young 12.5 Kid Nichols 12.2 Ted Breitenstein 9.7 Frank Killen 8.3 Red Ehret 7.9 Brickyard Kennedy 6.7 threshold